Непознаването на закона не е извинение.
(Латинска сентенция)
BG EN RU

Aggravated Theft under Article 195: Breaking In, Technical Devices, Prior Agreement and Repeat Offences

Not every theft is punished under the basic offence in Article 194. Where it is committed in a particular way, in special circumstances, by several people acting by prior agreement or as a repeat offence, the law provides for more severe penalties. These cases are governed mainly by Articles 195 and 196 of the Bulgarian Criminal Code.

What does “aggravated theft” mean?

Aggravated theft includes all the elements of ordinary theft: taking another’s movable property out of someone else’s possession without consent and with intent to appropriate it unlawfully. An additional circumstance makes the act more dangerous to society.

For the common cases under Article 195(1), the law provides for one to ten years’ imprisonment. The court may also order confiscation of up to half the offender’s assets. The precise classification depends on the method of taking, the property taken, the participants, any prior convictions and the other facts.

Theft by destroying or damaging a barrier

Theft carries a higher penalty if committed by destroying, damaging or undermining a barrier solidly constructed to protect people or property. Examples include breaking a door or window or damaging a lock, grille, fence, padlock or other protective structure.

Overcoming a physical obstacle does not automatically establish this offence. The questions are whether the barrier was solidly built for protection, whether it was actually destroyed or damaged and whether that act served to commit the theft.

Theft using a technical device

Use of a technical device can also make theft aggravated. What counts depends on the specific function the item served in committing the offence. It matters whether it facilitated entry, unlocking, dismantling or the taking itself.

Possible examples include tools for unlocking or breaking in, electronic devices, implements for overcoming security and tools for dismantling. Simply finding an item on the accused is not enough: its use and connection with the particular theft must be proved.

Use of a motor vehicle

Article 195 also provides for a higher penalty if a motor vehicle was used to commit the theft. The mere presence of a car nearby is not enough. What matters is whether the vehicle served a function in committing the crime, for example in taking the item directly or transporting it away as part of the method chosen in advance.

Theft by a special method

A “special method” means an unusual method or one that particularly facilitates the act and indicates a higher degree of danger to society. Each case must be assessed individually. The prosecution must identify and prove what made the method special; the court cannot rely on a general assertion alone.

Prior agreement between two or more persons

Theft by two or more persons who agreed in advance to commit it is also aggravated if the case is not minor. The agreement to act jointly must have been reached before the commission of the offence began.

The presence of several people at the scene does not in itself prove prior agreement. Each person’s role must be clarified: who took the items, provided access, kept watch or helped carry them away? Evidence may include communications, recordings, witness accounts and conduct before, during and after the act.

Theft by an official

The aggravated form applies where an official took advantage of their position to commit the theft. Both official status and the connection between that position and the facilitating of the taking must be proved.

If the item was entrusted to the person or was already lawfully in their possession, the question may instead be whether the act constitutes misappropriation or official embezzlement rather than theft.

Repeat offences and dangerous recidivism

Under the conditions in Article 28, an offence is repeated if it is committed after a conviction for another offence of the same kind has become final. Article 195(1) defines an aggravated form for a repeat offence where the case is not minor.

Dangerous recidivism under Article 29 has separate, stricter conditions. Where theft constitutes dangerous recidivism, Article 196 provides for two to ten years’ imprisonment for the basic form and three to fifteen years for the aggravated forms under Article 195(1) and (2). The nature of previous offences, the sentences imposed, whether they were suspended or actually served and the time elapsed all matter.

Theft of a motor vehicle

Where the property stolen is a motor vehicle, the law expressly provides for an aggravated form. This must be distinguished from unlawful taking of a motor vehicle under Article 346, where there is no intent to appropriate it. The decisive factor is the perpetrator’s intent, established through their actions and the other evidence.

Theft on a large or particularly large scale

For theft on a large scale, Article 195(2) provides for three to fifteen years’ imprisonment and possible confiscation of up to half the offender’s assets. For theft on a particularly large scale constituting a particularly serious case, Article 196a provides for ten to twenty years’ imprisonment and confiscation of all or part of the offender’s assets.

The value of the property at the time of the act is established by evidence and expert assessment. A “particularly serious case” also requires an exceptionally high degree of danger to society in view of the consequences and other aggravating circumstances.

Preparation and attempt

As a rule, preparation is punishable only if the law expressly says so. Article 195(5) penalises preparation for certain aggravated thefts, including ones involving destruction of or damage to barriers, use of a motor vehicle, a technical device or a special method, or theft of a motor vehicle. An attempt occurs when commission has begun but the offence is not completed for reasons beyond the perpetrator’s control.

What should be checked?

  • Have all elements of the basic theft offence been proved?
  • What particular protective barrier was involved, and was it actually damaged?
  • Was a technical device used and how was it connected with the taking?
  • Did a motor vehicle serve a function in the theft?
  • Have prior agreement and each person’s participation been proved?
  • Have repetition and dangerous recidivism been properly distinguished?
  • How was the value of the property determined?
  • Were the physical evidence, recordings and expert reports obtained lawfully?
  • Was the item returned or replaced, and does the more favourable provision in Article 197 apply?

For the basic elements of the offence, see “Theft under Article 194 of the Bulgarian Criminal Code: Elements, Penalties and Defence”.

Related articles

This article provides general information. The legal classification depends on the specific facts, the evidence and the applicable law.

For advice in a theft case, you can contact attorney Mihail Tomov of the Varna Bar Association.

Call for a consultation