Непознаването на закона не е извинение.
(Латинска сентенция)
BG EN RU

Removing one of two managers of a limited liability company: who calls the meeting and who votes?

Where two managers must act jointly, a conflict between them does not automatically entitle one to call a general meeting alone to remove the other. Voting rights must be assessed separately: removal as manager and a resolution to sue for damages are different matters.

Judgment No. 266 of 9 October 2026 in commercial case No. 2424/2024 of the Supreme Court of Cassation, Second Commercial Division, clarifies this distinction. The court ruled under Article 290 of the Code of Civil Procedure. This is a final judgment in a particular case, not an interpretative judgment or a question still awaiting an answer.

Read the articles of association first

The registration of two managers does not establish whether either may act alone. Check the current articles, subsequent amendments and the registered method of representation. Both internal management arrangements and representation in dealings with third parties matter.

The ruling concerns joint management by two managers who are also members. Under that arrangement, an invitation issued by the management body must express their joint will. The fact that the meeting is to consider removing one manager does not release the other from the agreed and statutory procedure.

Do not confuse removal from managerial office with expulsion as a member. The first affects the management function; the second affects membership of the company. Different conditions and voting rules apply.

What if the two managers cannot convene the meeting together?

Article 138(2) of the Commerce Act allows members holding more than one tenth of the capital to request a general meeting in writing. If the manager fails to convene it within two weeks, the requesting members may convene it themselves.

The Supreme Court of Cassation holds that this procedure must also be followed when the requesting member is one of the joint managers. Address the request to the management body consisting of both managers at the company’s management address. Receipt must be capable of proof. If the meeting has not been convened by the end of the period, the member may issue the invitation in the capacity of member.

It is not enough to assume in advance that the other manager will refuse. In the case considered, the court set aside the contested resolutions precisely because the meeting had been convened unlawfully.

The invitation and agenda also matter

Under Article 139(1) of the Commerce Act, each member must receive a written invitation at least seven days before the meeting unless the articles provide otherwise. The invitation must state the agenda.

When preparing, distinguish removal of a manager, possible election of a replacement, and a resolution to claim damages and appoint a representative for the proceedings. For each decision check who has authority, what majority is required and the prescribed form of the minutes.

Keep the documents sent and evidence of receipt. The dispatch date alone does not prove compliance with a deadline that runs by reference to receipt.

Does a member vote on their own removal as manager?

The court distinguishes this decision from expelling a member. The prohibition in Article 137(3) on voting on one’s own expulsion does not automatically extend to removal as manager. Nor does a management dispute alone justify applying Article 229 of the Commerce Act by analogy.

In the absence of an applicable statutory exception or a relevant permissible provision in the articles, the member participates in the vote on their own removal as manager. Do not exclude them from voting solely because they have a personal interest in retaining office.

Under the general rule, the remaining resolutions under Article 137(3) require more than half of the capital unless the articles provide otherwise. With equal shares of 50%, voting rights are decisive: half is not more than half. The actual calculation requires examination of the articles and the type of resolution.

What if the company seeks damages for acts of management?

The answer differs for a resolution under Article 137(1), point 8 to sue the manager and appoint a representative to conduct the action. The court allows the restriction in Article 229 to apply by analogy: the member whose financial liability as manager is being pursued does not vote on that resolution.

A resolution to sue does not itself prove that the manager caused loss. Liability under Article 145 of the Commerce Act is determined in separate court proceedings. Gather relevant contracts, payments, accounts, correspondence and other evidence of the alleged damage.

Do not take the same approach to voting rights on every agenda item. The same individual’s procedural position and rights within the company may differ depending on the resolution.

If the meeting has already taken place

A member may seek to set aside a resolution contrary to the law or the articles under Article 74 of the Commerce Act before the regional court for the company’s registered office. The action is brought against the company.

The time limit is 14 days from the meeting if the member attended or was duly invited. In other cases it is 14 days from learning of the resolution, but no later than three months from the meeting.

Prepare the following for a consultation:

  • the articles of association and all relevant amendments;
  • a record of the managers, powers of representation and shares;
  • the written request for a meeting and proof of receipt;
  • the invitation, agenda and documents proving service;
  • the minutes, attendance list and powers of attorney;
  • documents relating to the alleged breaches and losses;
  • details of entries applied for or made in the register and any court papers received.

Check separately what steps are needed in relation to the Commercial Register. A court challenge and registration proceedings raise different issues; the appropriate applications depend on the stage reached and the documents.

Tomovi Law Firm offers advice and representation in commercial and corporate disputes. Examining the articles, invitations and resolutions makes it possible to choose an appropriate procedure for convening a meeting, voting or seeking judicial protection in the particular case, without promising a particular outcome.

Call for a consultation