Road accident abroad: which law governs compensation from the insurer?
After a road accident in another country, identifying the insurer is not enough. You also need to establish which law governs compensation and limitation periods. The fact that the people involved are Bulgarian nationals does not, on its own, answer that question.
Start by drawing up a precise timeline and gathering documents on the accident, insurance and residence of those affected. Do not wait for a final refusal from the insurer before checking these matters.
Which rule is the starting point?
Where the Rome II Regulation applies, the general rule in Article 4(1) points to the law of the country where the direct damage occurred. Indirect consequences in another country do not in themselves change that starting point.
There are exceptions. Paragraph 2 takes account of whether the injured person and the person claimed to be liable had their habitual residence in the same country when the damage occurred. Paragraph 3 allows the law of another country to apply if the circumstances as a whole disclose a manifestly closer connection with it.
Do not assume that a registered permanent address or a passport provides all the necessary information. For the review, describe where those involved actually lived and worked at the time of the accident and which documents you can produce.
What questions remain before the Court of Justice of the EU?
By Order No. 207 of 22 January 2026 in commercial case No. 2553/2024, the Bulgarian Supreme Court of Cassation referred questions on the meaning of “the person claimed to be liable” in a direct action against an insurer. Whether this means the driver or the insurer may affect the exception based on common habitual residence. The reference was registered as Case C-45/26.
By Order No. 492 of 18 February 2026 in commercial case No. 1674/2025, the Supreme Court of Cassation referred further questions concerning the relationship between the rules in Article 4 and the identity of the injured person when a relative claims compensation for a death. This reference is Case C-137/26.
When checked on 22 October 2026, both cases were listed as pending in the Court of Justice’s official system. A question referred is not a ruling on the merits. Do not base your actions on an assumption about how the Court will rule.
A direct action against the insurer needs a separate assessment
Article 18 of Rome II allows a direct action if either the law applicable to the non-contractual obligation or the law applicable to the insurance contract provides for it. Bring the policy and its general terms if you have them.
Which court has jurisdiction must be established separately. Jurisdiction and the applicable substantive law are distinct questions. Do not choose a country in which to sue solely in the expectation that its compensation rules will automatically apply.
When corresponding with a claims representative, keep the insurer’s details and note the capacity in which the representative responds. Give your lawyer the complete correspondence, not just the latest letter.
Why are time limits particularly important?
Under Article 15(h) of Rome II, the applicable law governs limitation, including when the period starts, is suspended or is interrupted. Do not rely on a familiar time limit from a Bulgarian case without checking the law applicable to this accident.
For the initial review, record the dates of the accident, submission and receipt of the claim, replies, payments and any court proceedings. If you have already brought a case abroad, include all decisions recording how it ended, including any withdrawal of the claim.
Do not assume that negotiations, an email or earlier proceedings necessarily preserved your rights. The effect of each step must be assessed under the applicable rules. A pending case before the Court of Justice is likewise no reason to wait without an individual assessment of the time limits.
Which documents should you gather?
Gather the available documents in their original form:
- the accident report and details of those involved, the vehicles and the insurers;
- the policy, general terms and any vehicle registration documents you have;
- medical records, test results and evidence of treatment and expenses;
- the claim as submitted, its attachments, acknowledgements of receipt and all replies;
- settlement offers and documents showing the amounts received;
- court papers and details of service if proceedings have been brought;
- documents showing residence, employment or study at the time of the accident, where relevant to a dispute over habitual residence.
In a fatal accident, include the available evidence of death and of your relationship to the deceased. Note which documents are in a foreign language and which are missing. Discuss translation requirements once you know where and for what purpose the documents will be used.
Before accepting an offer of payment
Ask for clarification of what the offer covers and whether your signature entails waiving further claims. Submit the entire draft for review, including annexes and foreign-language text. Do not decide solely by comparing the amount offered with an award in another case.
Tomovi Law Firm provides legal assistance to road accident victims. A review of the documents allows the applicable law, time limits and steps needed for your particular claim to be assessed, without promising a particular outcome.



