A manager’s transaction harms the company: what remedies should you consider?
A manager has sold a company asset on unfavourable terms or assumed an apparently unjustified obligation. Start by establishing who signed, what loss is alleged and what is known about the conduct of the other party.
Start with the contract and the capacity in which it was signed
Obtain the entire contract, its annexes and the records of its performance. Check who represented the company on the transaction date and whether they could act individually or only jointly. If someone signed under a power of attorney, examine that instrument too. A transaction by the manager acting as an organ of the company and one through an authorised agent do not raise entirely the same issues.
Also check the articles of association, general meeting resolutions and payment records. Breach of an internal management rule does not automatically make the contract ineffective against the other party.
What does Article 40 of the Obligations and Contracts Act cover?
Article 40 protects the principal where the representative and the other party collude to the principal’s detriment. Both harm and bad faith on the part of the participants matter. A company member’s disagreement with the price does not in itself prove either requirement.
In cases involving representation, courts examine the terms at the time of contracting. Gather evidence of the asset’s value at that date, how the price was set, negotiations, actual payment and correspondence. Evidence of relationships between the parties may also be relevant, but must be assessed alongside the other evidence.
Why is the position disputed for a company manager?
Different panels of the Supreme Court of Cassation have reached different conclusions on applying Article 40 where a company acts through one of its organs. The question is whether the features of this type of representation exclude the rule or whether it can also protect the company against a harmful transaction entered into by its statutory representative.
Interpretative Case No. 4/2025 was opened before the General Assembly of the Civil and Commercial Divisions of the Supreme Court of Cassation to resolve the divergence. The review carried out for this article found no published final interpretative ruling on the question. Opinions in legal literature do not have the standing of such a ruling. For an individual dispute, check for subsequent developments in the case.
The effect of the contract and losses caused by management are separate issues
Whether the company has a remedy against the contract itself is distinct from the manager’s financial liability. For a limited liability company (OOD), Article 145 of the Commerce Act governs the manager’s liability for harm caused to the company. The basis of the claim, the breach, the loss and the causal link must be established separately.
Also determine who may act for the company. Being a member does not itself give you an unrestricted right to bring any claim in the company’s place. If relief is sought against the manager, establish at the outset who will represent the company in the dispute.
What should you prepare for a consultation?
- The contract, amendments and records of the transfer of assets.
- The articles of association, relevant resolutions and powers of attorney.
- Bank records and accounting data showing performance.
- Correspondence and evidence of value at the transaction date.
- Court papers received and proof of service.
If an asset may be transferred again, promptly discuss whether interim measures are needed. Filing a claim does not automatically impose a restraint on real property or an attachment of other assets. If you have already been served with a claim, do not wait for negotiations or the interpretative case to conclude before preparing your defence.
For advice about a transaction detrimental to the company, contact lawyer Mihail Tomov or another lawyer at Tomovi Law Firm. A review of the documents will help identify the appropriate remedy for your case.
Legal sources: Obligations and Contracts Act — Article 40; Commerce Act — Articles 141 and 145; Supreme Court of Cassation — opening of Interpretative Case No. 4/2025, General Assembly of the Civil and Commercial Divisions.
This article is for general information and does not constitute legal advice or a legal consultation. For advice on a particular case, consult a lawyer who can review the relevant documents.



