Road traffic accidents causing moderate or grievous bodily injury: criminal liability and defence
Not every collision in which someone is injured gives rise to criminal liability. For a traffic crime to be established, the driver must have breached a specific traffic rule, the breach must be a direct cause of the accident, and moderate or grievous bodily injury must have been caused through negligence. Medical classification of the injury and expert accident reconstruction are often decisive.
When does a road traffic accident constitute a crime?
The basic offence is defined in Article 343(1)(b), read together with Article 342(1), of the Criminal Code. All the following elements must be proved:
- driving a motor vehicle;
- breach of a specific rule in the Road Traffic Act or its implementing regulations;
- moderate or grievous bodily injury;
- a direct causal link between the breach and the injury;
- negligence with respect to the harmful outcome.
The fact that a collision occurred does not automatically prove fault. Not every technical breach is a cause of the outcome. The case law of the Supreme Court of Cassation stresses that direct causation must be established through a full analysis of the evidence and expert findings.
What is moderate bodily injury?
Moderate bodily injury is defined by Article 129 of the Criminal Code. It does not depend on the number of days spent in hospital or an everyday impression that an injury is “serious”. Statutory examples include:
- lasting difficulty moving a limb, the trunk or the neck;
- lasting impairment of sight or hearing;
- a fractured jaw or loss of teeth that impairs chewing or speech;
- disfigurement;
- permanent impairment of health that is not life-threatening;
- impairment of health that is temporarily life-threatening;
- a penetrating injury to the cranial, thoracic or abdominal cavity.
Fractures of a kind commonly sustained in road accidents may qualify as moderate bodily injury if they cause lasting difficulty with movement. A forensic medical expert assesses the nature and consequences of the particular injury.
What is grievous bodily injury?
Grievous bodily injury under Article 128 of the Criminal Code covers the most severe injuries, including prolonged disturbance of consciousness, permanent blindness in one or both eyes, loss of an organ or limb, loss of reproductive capacity, and permanent general impairment of health that is life-threatening.
The distinction between moderate and grievous bodily injury directly affects the legal classification and penalty. The medical assessment must therefore draw on the complete medical record, including imaging, surgery, follow-up treatment and lasting effects.
What penalties are prescribed?
For the basic offence under Article 343(1)(b) of the Criminal Code the penalty is:
- imprisonment for up to four years for grievous bodily injury;
- imprisonment for up to three years or probation for moderate bodily injury.
The court also disqualifies the driver from driving a motor vehicle. In setting the sentence it considers the violations, conduct after the accident, previous convictions, assistance given, the number and severity of the injuries, and any contribution by other participants.
When is liability more severe?
The law provides for aggravated offences and more severe penalties in circumstances such as:
- driving while intoxicated or after using narcotic substances;
- refusing the prescribed test without a medical reason in the cases to which the provision applies;
- fleeing the scene;
- driving without the required legal entitlement;
- causing bodily injury to more than one person;
- committing the act at a pedestrian crossing;
- exceeding the speed limit by a particularly large margin or driving through a red light in the circumstances specified by law.
The exact penalty depends on the version of the law in force on the date of the accident and the combination of aggravating elements established.
How is the course of the collision established?
Key evidence includes inspection of the scene, marks on the road and vehicles, photographs and video, electronic system data, witness testimony and expert accident reconstruction. The expert can examine speed, the distance needed to stop, visibility, reaction time and whether it was technically possible to avoid the accident.
Experts assist the court with specialist knowledge but do not decide the legal question of guilt. If findings are incomplete or contradictory, or rely on incorrect initial data, a supplementary, second or multidisciplinary expert opinion may be requested.
How does the injured person’s conduct affect the case?
A breach by a pedestrian, cyclist or another driver may be relevant to how the accident occurred and to sentencing. It does not automatically absolve the accused. It must be determined whether the accused’s own breach remains a direct cause of the outcome and whether the accident could have been prevented.
Failure to wear a seat belt may also be examined in relation to the nature and severity of the injuries. It does not erase the cause of the collision itself, but it can affect particular consequences and the amount of civil compensation.
Does giving assistance matter?
If the driver does everything within their power after the accident to help the injured person, the mitigated offence under Article 343a of the Criminal Code may apply, provided the statutory conditions are met. Merely making a token telephone call is not sufficient if the driver could reasonably have taken other steps.
The court considers whether the driver stopped immediately, secured the scene, gave accurate information when calling 112 and assisted medical teams, as well as how the driver acted until the authorities arrived.
Can proceedings be discontinued at the injured person’s request?
For the basic offence of causing moderate or grievous bodily injury, the law allows criminal proceedings to be discontinued at the injured person’s request in certain cases. This does not apply to all aggravated offences and is restricted if the offender has already benefited from such discontinuance within the period prescribed by law.
The injured person’s decision should be an informed one. Discontinuance of criminal proceedings does not necessarily extinguish civil claims or resolve matters between the injured person and the insurer.
Rights of the injured person
The injured person has the right to be informed of the progress of proceedings, make requests and objections, present evidence and appeal the decisions specified by law. At the trial stage, they may apply to participate as a private prosecuting party alongside the public prosecutor and bring a civil claim under the conditions of the Criminal Procedure Code.
Compensation may also be claimed from the motor third-party liability insurer for pain and suffering, treatment costs, lost income and other proven losses. Medical records, receipts and evidence of the length of recovery should be retained.
What should be checked?
- Which particular traffic rule was breached?
- Was that breach a direct cause of the accident and injury?
- Are the data used for the expert accident reconstruction correct?
- Was it technically possible for the driver to prevent the impact?
- How was the bodily injury classified, and are the medical records complete?
- Did another participant’s conduct or failure to wear a seat belt contribute?
- Is an aggravating element of the offence present?
- Was real assistance provided after the accident?
- Was the period of provisional licence withdrawal correctly credited?
- Were the injured person’s rights and civil claims protected in good time?
For related topics, see our articles on driving after drinking alcohol, driving after drug use and refusing a test.
If you need advice on criminal proceedings arising from a road traffic accident causing moderate or grievous bodily injury, you can contact a lawyer who practises criminal law, such as Mihail Tomov, a member of the Varna Bar Association.
This article provides general information and does not constitute legal advice on a particular case. The applicable law is the version in force on the date of the accident.



