Refusing an alcohol or drug test: consequences and defence
Refusing an alcohol or drug test has consequences for the driver. Depending on the circumstances, it may be an administrative offence or a crime. The decisive issues are whether the driver was involved in a road traffic accident, whether they have previously been penalised for refusal, and exactly how the check and medical examination were conducted and documented.
What counts as a refusal?
The law covers several distinct forms of conduct:
- refusing an alcohol test using a testing device;
- refusing a test for narcotic substances or their analogues;
- failing to comply with an instruction to undergo testing with an evidential analyser;
- failing to attend within the specified time or refusing a medical examination and the collection of biological samples.
Merely entering the word “refusal” in a document is not enough. It must be established what specific test was offered, whether the driver was told what was required, whether a testing referral was issued and served, and whether the driver had a real opportunity to comply.
When is refusal an administrative offence?
Where the driver was not involved in a road traffic accident and the conditions for a criminal offence are not met, refusal is generally penalised under Article 174(3) of the Road Traffic Act.
The prescribed penalties are:
- a fine of 2,000 leva;
- disqualification from driving a motor vehicle for two years;
- deduction of 15 licence points.
These are fixed penalties, not a range within which the authority is free to choose. Compulsory administrative measures may also be taken: temporary withdrawal of the licence until liability is determined and, under the statutory conditions, a measure affecting the vehicle’s registration.
Does refusing both tests constitute one offence or two?
In Interpretative Decision No. 13 of 20 December 2021, the Supreme Administrative Court held that refusing an alcohol test and refusing a drug test are two separate administrative offences. Where two distinct refusals have been duly established, separate penalties may be imposed for each.
Refusing the initial test and subsequently failing to comply with the testing referral is a separate issue. The precise legal classification depends on how the conduct is described in the offence report and penalty decree, and on the applicable case law.
When is a repeat refusal a crime?
Article 343b(6) of the Criminal Code provides for criminal liability where a driver refuses a duly requested check or fails to comply with a testing instruction after having already received an administrative penalty for either of those acts.
The prescribed penalty is imprisonment for up to six months and a fine of 2,000 to 5,000 leva. The court also disqualifies the driver from driving a motor vehicle. The contents of the previous penalty decree and the date on which it became final are important to the legal classification.
Refusal after a road traffic accident
For acts committed after 29 July 2025, Article 343b(7) of the Criminal Code provides for a separate offence. A driver who, after involvement in a road traffic accident, refuses a duly requested alcohol and/or drug test or fails to comply with a testing instruction is punishable by imprisonment for up to one year and a fine of 2,500 leva.
This offence does not require an earlier administrative penalty for refusal. However, the driver’s involvement in the accident, the specific request for a check or examination, and a knowing refusal must all be proved.
When does a cause beyond the driver’s control exclude punishment?
Under Article 343b(8) of the Criminal Code, the person is not punished if refusal under paragraph 6 or 7 was due to circumstances beyond their control. Such circumstances are not presumed: they must be established by medical records, witness testimony or other evidence.
Physical inability to provide a particular sample does not necessarily amount to refusal. It matters whether a permissible alternative test was offered, what the medical professional recorded and whether the driver’s conduct indicated unwillingness or genuine inability.
Refusing a roadside test and giving a blood sample
It is a common mistake to assume that providing blood later automatically cancels out an earlier refusal to be tested at the roadside. The two acts must be assessed in their exact sequence and under the applicable provisions. Likewise, refusing a blood sample after a positive roadside test does not mean there is no evidence: under certain conditions, the roadside result may retain evidential value.
The rules governing the check, the referral, deadlines and samples are set out in Ordinance No. 1 of 19 July 2017.
Is the vehicle forfeited?
Mandatory vehicle forfeiture or payment of its equivalent value under Article 343b(5) of the Criminal Code is prescribed for the offences in paragraphs 1–4: driving after alcohol or drug use. It does not automatically extend to offences consisting solely of refusal under paragraphs 6 and 7.
This does not rule out other measures under the Road Traffic Act or temporary detention of the vehicle where a separate legal basis exists. A final court order for forfeiture, termination of registration and seizure as evidence must therefore be distinguished.
What should be checked?
- Did the driver actually drive the vehicle?
- What specific test was offered, and did the competent authority conduct the check?
- Was there a clear, unambiguous refusal and how was it documented?
- Was a testing referral issued and properly served?
- Were the place and time limit for attendance specified, and could the driver actually comply?
- Was there an objective medical reason or another cause beyond the driver’s control?
- Did a road traffic accident occur, and was the driver’s involvement proved?
- Was there a previous final administrative penalty for refusal?
- Do the facts as described support the legal classification?
- Were the time limits for issuing and challenging the decisions observed?
Appeals and practical steps
An order imposing a compulsory administrative measure and a penalty decree are distinct decisions, each subject to its own appeal procedure. Challenging one does not take the place of challenging the other. Where there are indications of a crime, the defence must also keep track of the criminal proceedings.
The driver should obtain copies of the offence report, referral, test record and order, avoid signing documents they have not read or that have not been completed, and preserve medical evidence promptly. Short procedural time limits make early legal advice particularly important.
For related issues, see our articles on driving after drinking alcohol and driving after drug use.
If you need advice about refusing a test or medical examination, you can contact a lawyer who practises criminal law, such as Mihail Tomov, a member of the Varna Bar Association.
This article provides general information and does not constitute legal advice on a particular case. The applicable law is the version in force on the date of the act.



