Employer liability for pain and suffering caused by an occupational accident
To establish an employer’s liability for non-pecuniary harm suffered by a worker or employee injured in an occupational accident, the claimant’s lawyer must prove in full the following elements in court, in accordance with the burden of proof under Article 154(1) of the Code of Civil Procedure: (1) an occupational accident; (2) harm resulting in pain and suffering; and (3) a causal link between the accident and that harm. The pain and suffering must be a natural consequence of an accident that occurred in the course of and in connection with, or on the occasion of, the work performed, including work carried out in the enterprise’s interest. The employer’s liability arises whether or not the employer, one of its governing bodies or another worker or employee was at fault; the article draws this conclusion from Article 200(2) of the Labour Code. Liability under Article 200(1) is strict: the injured person’s negligence does not in itself release the employer from the obligation to pay compensation. Intentional self-injury excludes liability, but consciously taking a risk in the belief that harm will not occur does not. Even where the injured person contributed to the harm in this way, Article 201(2) of the Labour Code provides for a reduction in liability in cases of gross negligence, not its complete exclusion.
Money cannot undo pain and suffering. The award for non-pecuniary harm is a monetary substitute rather than reimbursement of a calculable loss. Article 52 of the Obligations and Contracts Act therefore allows the court to determine, on equitable grounds, the amount the employer owes the employee for pain and suffering that naturally resulted from the injuries sustained in the accident. The court must consider the nature and intensity of the injured person’s suffering and their age, applying society’s standard of fairness at the time the right to compensation arose. As the Plenum of the Supreme Court explained in Decree No. 4/1968, fairness under Article 52 is not an abstract concept. In fixing the award the court must assess the specific, objectively ascertainable circumstances of the case.
This article does not give a legal opinion or advice about a particular situation or person. For assistance in a similar case, consult a lawyer who practises labour and tort law.
For legal advice on workplace accidents and compensation for injured workers and their families, you can contact Tomovi Law Firm.



