Evidence in a theft case: CCTV, witnesses and identification
In a theft case, the decisive question is often not whether an item is missing, but whether the evidence establishes beyond reasonable doubt who took it, in what circumstances and with what intent. A video recording, identification by a witness or recovery of the item can be important, but no piece of evidence carries predetermined weight. Each must be tested and assessed alongside all the other evidence in the case.
What must be proved?
In a theft case the prosecution must establish both that the item is missing and that the particular person charged was involved. The following questions are usually examined:
- what movable property was taken and who owns it;
- from whose possession it was taken and whether consent was lacking;
- who took it;
- whether there was an intent to appropriate it;
- the value of the item and the financial loss caused;
- whether there are circumstances amounting to aggravated theft – for example, a break-in, use of a technical device or prior agreement;
- whether the offence was completed or remained an attempted theft.
Under the Bulgarian Code of Criminal Procedure, in cases subject to public prosecution the burden of proving the charge rests with the prosecutor and the investigating authorities. The accused does not have to prove their innocence.
Security camera recordings
Footage from a shop, building entrance, car park or other premises may show people’s movements, the moment an item was taken or what happened afterwards. To assess it properly, it is important to check:
- who provided the recording and which system produced it;
- whether the original file was handed over or only a clip, still image or re-recording;
- whether the metadata and the full sequence before and after the event have been preserved;
- whether the system date and time were correct;
- whether there are interruptions, editing, compression or missing frames;
- whether the resolution, lighting and camera angle allow reliable identification.
Case law allows recordings made by private security systems outside criminal proceedings to be admitted and assessed as physical evidence. Their authenticity and content can be checked through inspection and technical expert examination. An indistinct silhouette or visual resemblance alone should not automatically be treated as conclusive identification.
Witness testimony
A witness can report only facts they personally perceived. Relevant factors when assessing testimony include the viewing conditions, distance, duration, lighting, stress, whether the witness knew the person and the time between the event and questioning.
It is also necessary to check whether the account is consistent, whether other evidence supports it and whether the witness has an interest in the outcome. Differences between initial accounts and later testimony must be clarified rather than simply disregarded.
Identification of a person or object
Identification is a distinct investigative procedure governed by Articles 169–171 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. Before it takes place, the identifying witness must be questioned about the features by which they could recognise the person or object and the conditions in which they saw them.
A person to be identified is presented alongside at least three other people of similar appearance. The person must not be shown to the witness beforehand. If presentation in person is impossible, a photograph may be used, again alongside at least three similar photographs. If there is more than one identifying witness, each takes part separately.
Seeing the suspect beforehand on social media, in the news, in police photographs or in the corridor before the procedure may affect the reliability of the identification and should be investigated.
Recovery of the stolen item
Finding the item in the accused’s possession or at a place connected with them is significant, but does not automatically prove they took it. Relevant factors include the time between the theft and recovery, the features that identify the item, access by other people and the explanation for how it was acquired.
The precise manner of seizure must also be checked: was the item described in detail in the official record and photographed, were the required persons present, and can the item presented in the case be traced back to the object seized?
Traces, expert examinations and digital data
Fingerprints, DNA or other traces may link a person to an object or place, but it must be established when and how they were left. If the person had lawful access, the trace may have another explanation.
Experts may examine recordings, traces and damaged locks, and assess the value of the property. Valuation is particularly important because it may affect the legal classification of the offence and whether it qualifies as a minor case.
Messages, location data, telephone contacts and sale listings may also be relevant. It is necessary to check the legal procedure by which they were obtained, who owns the account or device and whether each extract was considered in its full context.
What needs to be checked?
- is there evidence both of the taking and of who committed it;
- have the original recordings and digital files been preserved;
- were the search, seizure and identification procedures lawful;
- are there discrepancies between witness accounts and objective evidence;
- has the recovered item been specifically identified and has its ownership been proved;
- was the value correctly determined and does a more favourable legal classification apply;
- have the facts supporting the accused’s account been considered?
The accused’s statements are a means of proof, but the accused has the right to remain silent. A refusal to give an account cannot fill gaps in the evidence. The ultimate assessment must be based on the evidence as a whole and respect the presumption of innocence.
Why early defence action matters
CCTV recordings are often overwritten automatically, digital data can be lost and witnesses’ memories change over time. A timely request to preserve and admit evidence may therefore be decisive. For the general elements of the offence, see also “Theft under Article 194 of the Bulgarian Criminal Code”.
Related articles
This article provides general information and does not constitute legal advice on a particular case.
If you need advice on a criminal law matter, you can contact lawyer Mihail Tomov of the Varna Bar Association.



