Expelled as a member and removed as manager: which resolutions can you challenge?
If the same general meeting first expels you as a member of a Bulgarian limited liability company and then removes you as manager, your challenge must identify the right resolutions. The Supreme Court of Cassation permits a joint challenge to both under the conditions explained in its interpretative judgment of 31 May 2023.
First establish the sequence of votes, what the minutes record and the time limit for bringing proceedings. General disagreement with the other members’ conduct cannot replace a specific request to the court.
Expulsion and removal are separate decisions
Membership and managerial office are distinct. Someone may hold a share and also manage the company, but the resolutions terminating those two positions must be examined separately.
It is therefore not enough to say you challenge the minutes. Identify which resolutions you contest, on what grounds and what relief you seek for each. Review other agenda items too where they relate to the termination of membership.
What challenge does the court allow after expulsion?
Point 2 of Interpretative Judgment No. 1/2020 of 31 May 2023 of the General Assembly of the Commercial Division of the Supreme Court of Cassation allows an action under Article 74(1) of the Commerce Act contesting removal as manager, joined with an action challenging expulsion as member, where expulsion was resolved under an earlier item at the same meeting.
In its reasons the court links effective protection to the ability to challenge both the expulsion and decisions at the same meeting that relate to it or follow from it.
This does not give a former member an unconditional right to challenge every future resolution. A different meeting, a different subject or an unchallenged expulsion requires separate assessment. Admissibility does not mean the court will necessarily allow the claim on its merits.
What is the time limit for bringing the action?
Under Article 74(2) of the Commerce Act the deadline is:
- 14 days from the date of the meetingif you attended or were duly invited;
- in other cases, 14 days from learning of the resolution, but no later than three months from the date of the meeting.
Check the invitation date, whether service was proper and whether you attended. Do not wait for negotiations between members or developments in the company’s register file to conclude before seeking legal advice.
An Article 74 action is brought against the company before the regional court for its registered office. It provides a remedy against resolutions contrary to mandatory statutory provisions or the company’s articles of association.
What should you prepare for your lawyer?
Gather these documents in chronological order:
- the articles of association and relevant amendments;
- the meeting invitation and proof of when and how it was served;
- the expulsion warning, if sent;
- the full minutes, attendance list and powers of attorney used;
- documents showing your membership and election as manager;
- applications in the company’s register file, the accompanying papers and details of entries already made;
- correspondence and other evidence relating to the alleged breaches.
Record separately the dates of the meeting, receipt of the documents and discovery of the resolutions. If anything is missing, specify what. Do not postpone the initial review simply because you are waiting for a copy of the minutes.
The action and a stay of registration require separate consideration
Do not assume that bringing an action automatically halts changes submitted to the Commercial Register. Under Article 19(7) of the Commercial Register and Register of Non-Profit Legal Entities Act, registration may be stayed on the basis of a court order, including under Article 536 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
If an application is pending, counsel should assess the grounds and specific scope of a request for a stay. If the entry has already been made, determine the appropriate subsequent remedy. A stay cannot be guaranteed in every case.
Why does the precise remedy matter?
The defect, relief sought and evidence must be assessed against the actual papers. The practical risk is that only some resolutions will be challenged or that the defence will rely on an unchecked assumption about the deadline.
Tomovi Law Firm provides advice and representation in commercial and corporate disputes, including expulsion of members, removal of managers and challenges to general meeting resolutions. Reviewing the documents allows the appropriate applications and deadlines to be identified, without promising a particular outcome.



