A debt collector and an invalid credit agreement: who can demand repayment of the principal?
Selling a claim to a debt collection company does not settle questions about the validity of the consumer credit agreement. In a dispute, check separately how much is owed and whether that particular company is entitled to collect it.
What to check if the agreement is invalid
If the agreement is declared invalid, Article 23 of the Consumer Credit Act provides for repayment of the net amount of credit without interest or other credit costs. This does not automatically mean that the entire amount labelled “principal” in the repayment schedule remains due. Work out what was actually advanced and what has been paid.
The grounds in Article 22 of the Act are assessed against the individual agreement. A discrepancy between the expected and claimed amounts does not in itself establish invalidity.
What changes when the claim is assigned?
Article 26 preserves the consumer’s defences against the new creditor, including set-off. It also requires the agreement to permit assignment.
Where the agreement is disputed, the legal review should cover the assignment agreement and the documents identifying the specific claim. It is particularly important to establish whether the company is claiming a contractual debt or restitution of a sum received under an invalid agreement. The notice of assignment alone cannot answer all these questions.
How to prepare the documents
Gather together:
- the credit agreement, general terms and all amendments;
- the repayment schedule and disbursement records;
- contracts for insurance or additional services linked to the credit;
- bank statements, receipts and other proof of payment;
- the notice of assignment, its envelope and enclosed statements;
- court papers and notices from the enforcement officer, if received.
Request a written breakdown: what amount is claimed, for which period and on what basis? Note discrepancies between it and your own payment records.
When to act quickly
If court papers arrive, immediately check the deadline and the appropriate procedural response. Keep evidence of the date and method of service. Do not wait for the collector to answer a document request before arranging a review of the court papers.
Before signing an acknowledgement of debt, instalment arrangement or settlement, establish which amounts and grounds you are accepting. Give your lawyer the whole document, including annexes. A calculation and the complete correspondence allow you to discuss possible defences and practical options without any promise of a particular outcome.
Tomovi Law Firm advises on disputes over obligations and contracts after reviewing the relevant documents.



