Непознаването на закона не е извинение.
(Латинска сентенция)
BG EN RU

Botox injections by someone who is not a doctor: possible criminal liability

Botulinum toxin injections for aesthetic purposes are often presented as an ordinary beauty treatment. In legal terms, however, the procedure involves injecting a medicinal product into the human body and may give rise to both administrative and criminal liability. When the person giving the injections is not qualified to practise medicine, the legal assessment depends on how the injections were given, the number of procedures, how the person presented themselves to clients, the origin of the product and the consequences.

What is a botulinum toxin product?

Botulinum toxin is a neurotoxin that temporarily blocks the transmission of nerve impulses to certain muscles. In aesthetic medicine it is used to temporarily reduce expression lines; in other areas of medicine it is used for certain neurological, ophthalmic and other conditions.

According to information published by the Ministry of Health, Botox, that is, botulinum toxin, is a prescription-only medicinal product to be administered for the appropriate therapeutic indications and at the prescribed dose. At the time the Ministry published its information, six medicinal products containing botulinum toxin were registered on the Bulgarian market. Five were also indicated for temporarily improving the appearance of wrinkles in the upper face.

Botulinum toxin should not be confused with dermal fillers. Botox is a medicinal product that acts on neuromuscular transmission. Fillers generally add volume, have a different composition and are subject to different regulatory rules. What both procedures have in common is an injection that carries medical risks.

Is an aesthetic procedure involving an injection a medical activity?

Relevant here is a judgment of the Sofia City Administrative Court in a dispute concerning fillers injected into the lower eyelid area at a beauty studio. The court held that this particular procedure constituted a medical activity. The medical standard in force at the time listed injectable treatments for facial wrinkles among interventions of limited scope and complexity. The studio was not registered as a medical establishment, and the court found a breach of Article 39 of the Medical Establishments Act.

The judgment concerns fillers, and its reasoning rests in part on the rules in force at the relevant time. It should therefore not be applied indiscriminately to every case involving botulinum toxin. The court’s assessment nevertheless offers useful guidance: a facial injection does not become an ordinary beauty treatment simply because it takes place in a beauty salon.

Practising a medical profession without the required qualifications

The main offence to consider is that under Article 324 of the Criminal Code. The law provides for liability where a person practises a profession or trade without the necessary qualification. Where the profession concerns the provision of healthcare to the public, the aggravated offence under Article 324(2) of the Criminal Code applies.

To substantiate a charge, it is not enough merely to establish that a needle pierced the skin. It must be proved that the person actually carried out work characteristic of a medical profession without the qualification required to do so. Relevant evidence may include:

  • advertising and public offers of the procedures;
  • appointment bookings and conversations with clients;
  • payments received;
  • the number of procedures performed;
  • use of a consulting room, medical equipment and records;
  • how the person described their professional status to clients.

Where procedures were performed repeatedly as part of a common plan, the prosecution may also examine whether the conditions for a continued offence under Article 26 of the Criminal Code are met. In an isolated case, whether the conduct amounts to “practising a profession” requires particularly careful assessment of the facts.

Liability where bodily injury is caused

If the procedure results in moderate or grievous bodily injury, Article 134 of the Criminal Code may be relevant. It covers bodily injury caused through lack of knowledge or negligent performance of an occupation or other legally regulated activity that is a source of increased danger. The law provides for more severe treatment where the person is not entitled to carry out the activity in question.

Application of this provision requires a medical expert assessment and proof of a causal link between the procedure and the injury. An unsatisfactory cosmetic result alone does not necessarily constitute bodily injury under the Criminal Code. The nature, duration and severity of the harm are assessed: for example, permanent disfigurement, impaired vision, neurological disorders, difficulty moving or a general impairment of health.

Where the injury is less serious, offences involving minor bodily injury may be considered. The precise classification depends on the form of fault and the specific medical consequences. If the procedure causes death, Article 123 of the Criminal Code may be relevant: causing death through lack of knowledge or negligent performance of a legally regulated activity that is a source of increased danger.

Fraud and use of forged documents

If the person knowingly posed as a doctor, claimed a specialist qualification they did not hold, or misled the client about the origin or nature of the product, the conditions for fraud under Article 209 of the Criminal Code may also be examined. The deception must have been used with the aim of obtaining a financial or other material gain and must have caused financial or other property loss.

If forged diplomas, certificates, prescriptions or medical documents were presented or used, the provisions on document offences, including Articles 308 and 316 of the Criminal Code, may also apply. False advertising claims do not in themselves prove fraud or a document offence: all the elements of the particular offence must be established.

What is checked about the product itself?

The investigation goes beyond the qualifications of the person who administered the injection. Investigators also check:

  • the exact name of the product and its manufacturer;
  • the batch number, expiry date and integrity of the packaging;
  • whether the product is authorised for use and was lawfully acquired;
  • how it was imported, sold and dispensed;
  • the required prescription and medical records;
  • the transport conditions, temperature controls and storage;
  • the dose, site of administration and compliance with medical requirements.

An unidentified, falsified or unlawfully imported product may give rise to additional administrative or criminal liability. The precise offence depends on the origin of the product, how it was distributed and the danger established by the evidence, rather than on the trade name “Botox” alone.

What evidence matters?

If there are indications that botulinum toxin was administered unlawfully, retain the receipt or proof of payment, the advertisement, correspondence, photographs taken before and after the procedure, the packaging or a photograph of the vial, the informed consent form and all medical records. Prompt medical examination and documentation of symptoms over time can be decisive in proving causation.

A report may be made to the police or the prosecution service, as well as to the competent health authorities: the relevant regional health inspectorate, the Executive Agency for Medical Supervision or the Bulgarian Drug Agency, depending on the nature of the violation. The injured person may also seek compensation for pecuniary and non-pecuniary damage.

Is every complication a crime?

No. A complication can occur even where a medical procedure is performed correctly. Criminal liability is personal and requires proof of a specific act, fault and, where the offence so requires, a causal link to the outcome. Conversely, a signed informed consent form does not make an activity lawful when performed by an unqualified person or automatically relieve that person of liability.

Distinguishing an administrative violation, civil liability and a criminal offence requires analysis of all the records, expert findings and the participants’ conduct. The applicable law is the version in force at the time of the act.

If you need advice on a similar case, you can contact a lawyer who practises criminal law, such as Mihail Tomov, a member of the Varna Bar Association. See also our page on criminal law and defence in criminal proceedings.

This article provides general information and does not constitute legal or medical advice on any particular case.

Call for a consultation