Minors facing remand in custody: why does the individual assessment matter?
When a minor is charged with an offence and remand in custody is sought, preparing the defence includes gathering specific information about the child’s development, health, education and family environment. The individual assessment report matters to that decision. It does not guarantee release or replace examination of the grounds for detention.
First identify the order restricting the child’s liberty
Ask for the available documents and find out where the child is, which authority is conducting the proceedings and whether a hearing has been scheduled. Note the times of actual detention and service of the orders. The police order, the prosecutor’s order and the court ruling must each be examined separately.
Defence counsel is mandatory for an accused minor under Article 94(1), point 1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. A parent’s presence does not replace a lawyer.
Detention is exceptional and requires an individual assessment
Article 386 of the Code provides for remand in custody in exceptional cases and allows various forms of supervision. If necessary to bring the minor before the court, the prosecutor may order detention for up to 48 hours. This period must be distinguished from the duration of court-ordered remand.
Article 10 of Directive (EU) 2016/800 requires deprivation of a child’s liberty to be a last resort for the shortest appropriate period, taking into account age, individual circumstances and the facts of the case. Detention remains possible if the statutory conditions are met, but a case-specific assessment is required.
What should the individual assessment report show?
Under Article 387 of the Code, an inspector from the juvenile police unit prepares the report after the charge has been formally presented. It covers maturity, family and social environment, vulnerabilities and risk factors. The minor participates, as do relatives and other informed persons where appropriate. Significant new circumstances require the report to be updated.
The family’s practical task is to provide verifiable facts. Labels such as ‘a good child’ or ‘a difficult personality’ say little about daily life, needs or available support. Explain who actually cares for the child, what the school day looks like and what difficulties have already been identified.
Article 7 of Directive (EU) 2016/800 links individual assessment to specific needs for protection, education and social integration. The information is also relevant when considering coercive procedural measures. The report should describe this particular child and their current circumstances.
What should you give defence counsel?
- the charging order and all detention orders;
- details of the school, attendance and educational support needed;
- medical records and information on current treatment;
- available social reports and records of work with specialists;
- information on housing, caregivers and their actual capacity to supervise;
- any earlier orders and measures, with their exact dates and contents.
Distinguish documented facts from your own observations. If treatment, residence or care arrangements have changed, state when and how this can be proved. Tell counsel about unfavourable circumstances too, so the defence can be prepared on the full facts.
How can you propose supervision?
If proposing parental supervision or another arrangement allowed by law, describe how it would work. Who will be with the child, how will schooling continue and how will attendance at proceedings and necessary assistance be ensured? Present a realistic plan that takes account of working hours and conditions at home.
Do not make promises you cannot keep. Counsel must assess how the proposal addresses the specific grounds in the detention application. A supportive environment alone does not answer every question about remand.
If the report is incomplete or out of date
Tell counsel exactly what is missing or inaccurate: treatment not recorded, a wrong address, support not taken into account or outdated information. Gather documents supporting the correction. Do not try to edit the official report yourself.
If the report is not yet ready, promptly discuss what applications to make and how to present the information already available about the child. Its absence does not mean automatic release. Once the court rules, immediately give counsel the ruling and details of notification so the applicable deadline can be checked.
Article 388b of the Code protects the report under Article 387 from disclosure. Do not post the document or sensitive information about the child on social media.
For advice, contact lawyer Mihail Tomov or another lawyer at Tomovi Law Firm. The firm provides defence in criminal proceedings after reviewing the orders and circumstances, without promising release or a particular outcome.
Legislation
- Code of Criminal Procedure — Articles 94, 386, 387 and 388b.
- Directive (EU) 2016/800 — Articles 7 and 10.
This article provides general information and does not constitute legal advice or a legal consultation. For advice on a specific case, consult a lawyer who can review the relevant documents.



