Freedom of expression and the protection of dignity and reputation
1. Freedom of Expression as a Fundamental Right
Freedom of expression is one of the fundamental rights in a democratic society. It guarantees the ability to freely express opinions, criticism, and assessments, including on matters of public interest. This right is a prerequisite for pluralism, public debate, and accountability, and therefore enjoys a high level of protection.
However, freedom of expression is not an absolute right. Its exercise must take place within the framework of the legal order and with due regard to other protected values, among which honor, dignity, and reputation occupy a particularly important place.
2. The Need for a Balance between Competing Rights
Freedom of expression can conflict with the protection of personal rights when the expression of an opinion, statement, or evaluation affects the intangible personal interests of another individual. In such cases, the law is faced with the need to achieve a fair balance between two competing constitutional values.
Criminal-law protection against insult and defamation should not be perceived as an unjustified restriction on freedom of expression, but as a means of preventing abuses of that right. Legal intervention is justified only where the exercise of freedom of expression exceeds the limits of what is permissible and results in unjustified interference with the personal sphere.
3. Permissible Criticism and Impermissible Infringement of Personality
The law draws a clear distinction between permissible criticism and punishable infringement of honor and reputation. The expression of an opinion, even if sharp or negative, does not in itself constitute unlawful conduct, provided it takes place within the framework of public debate and does not contain insulting language or false factual statements.
It is impermissible, however, to use freedom of expression to disseminate statements that undermine personal dignity or attribute disgraceful qualities or facts without basis. In such cases, speech ceases to be a means of public dialogue and becomes a means of harming another person’s dignity or reputation.
4. Criminal-Law Intervention as a Measure of Last Resort
Criminal law intervenes as a measure of last resort (ultima ratio), when other means of protection prove insufficient. The criminalization of insult and defamation aims not to sanction every inconvenient or unpleasant statement, but to provide protection against serious and unjustified infringements of intangible personal interests.
In assessing whether an offense has been committed, various circumstances must be taken into account, including the context of the statement, its form, the purpose of the expression, and its impact on the affected individual. Criminal liability is justified only where these factors indicate a substantial violation of the personal sphere.
5. Importance of the Balance for Law Enforcement
Maintaining a balance between freedom of expression and the protection of personality is essential for the proper application of criminal-law norms. Excessive intervention may have a “chilling effect” on free expression, while the absence of adequate protection would lead to the devaluation of honor and dignity as legal interests.
Therefore, law enforcement must be careful and precise, conducting an individual assessment of the competing interests in each specific case. Only in this way can effective protection of personality be ensured while preserving the genuine exercise of freedom of expression.
6. Practical consequences of insult and defamation
Speech that goes beyond permissible criticism may give rise to both criminal and civil liability. Under the provisions effective from 29 July 2025, the fine for the basic offence of insult is BGN 500 to 3,000; for the basic offence of defamation it is BGN 1,000 to 7,000. In aggravated cases under Article 148 of the Criminal Code, the fine can reach BGN 10,000 for insult and BGN 15,000 for defamation. The law also provides for public censure.
As a rule, the injured person brings a private criminal complaint. The time limit is six months from the day the injured person learned that the offence had been committed. Compensation for the harm suffered may be sought separately.
For a fuller discussion of the distinction, see the articles on insult, defamation and the liability of journalists and media outlets. For advice on a particular dispute, you can consult lawyer Mihail Tomov.



