Непознаването на закона не е извинение.
(Латинска сентенция)
BG EN RU

An evasive manoeuvre in a road accident: when does the defence of necessity apply?

A driver swerves to avoid a collision but causes another accident in the process. Saying ‘I tried to prevent a crash’ helps explain what happened but does not in itself rule out liability. The danger, possible responses and harm caused must be examined.

A legal review requires reconstructing the whole sequence before impact. What matters is not just the final turn of the wheel but also speed, following distance, visibility and when the danger could first have been perceived.

What does necessity mean?

Article 13 of the Criminal Code deals with acts done to protect personal, property or public interests from imminent danger. It requires that the danger could not have been avoided otherwise and that the harm caused was less serious than the harm prevented.

These conditions must be considered together. A sudden emergency is not enough. Was there another realistic way to avoid the danger, and what were the consequences of the response chosen?

There is therefore no general rule that moving into another lane or leaving the carriageway is always justified. The legal assessment depends on how the evidence shows the particular accident occurred.

What does the case law of the Supreme Court of Cassation show?

In Judgment No. 213 of 14 January 2019 in Criminal Case No. 970/2018, Third Criminal Division, the Court rejected reliance on an evasive manoeuvre where violations concerning speed and following distance were causally connected to the accident. The Court also examined whether a timely response could technically have prevented impact.

In the same judgment the Court stated that a driver cannot rely on necessity where the manoeuvre caused the death of a person who did not contribute to creating the danger. Those findings concern specific facts and cannot replace the examination of a different accident.

The practical point is that the defence must look beyond the last second before the collision. Check whether the driver’s earlier conduct created the situation in which stopping or avoiding impact was no longer possible.

Necessity and an accidental act are different

Under Article 15 of the Criminal Code the question is whether the driver had a duty or the ability to foresee the socially dangerous consequences. That is different from weighing danger, alternatives and harm under Article 13.

An event that seemed unexpected to a participant is not necessarily an accidental act in law. Give a precise account of what you saw and when you reacted. If you cannot remember a speed or distance, say so rather than presenting an estimate as fact.

What questions matter in an expert accident reconstruction?

Questions to discuss with your lawyer include:

  • What were the speeds and paths of travel before the danger arose?
  • At what point was the danger objectively perceptible?
  • What distance and time were available for reaction and stopping?
  • Was it technically possible to avoid impact?
  • How do physical traces, vehicle deformation, recordings and witness accounts fit together?
  • How do the technical conclusions change under different accounts of the facts?

These are examples to aid preparation, not standard instructions for every expert. The expert answers technical questions; the legal assessment of necessity is for the court. Identify precisely any disputed starting assumptions on which the report relies.

What should you keep after the accident?

If anyone is injured or in immediate danger, call 112. Preserving evidence must not interfere with assistance or put you at risk.

For a consultation, collect the accident report and diagram, photographs, witness details, medical records and papers received. If there is dashcam footage, keep the original, including the periods before and after impact. Promptly tell your lawyer and the investigating authority about any known cameras, since footage may be overwritten.

Also provide all expert reports and supplementary opinions you have. Do not edit the originals or substitute a short selected extract for the complete recording.

Does necessity mean no compensation is due?

Criminal liability and compensation for damage are separate matters. Article 46(2) of the Obligations and Contracts Act expressly provides for compensation for damage caused in a situation of necessity. Who is liable, on what basis and whether insurance covers the loss require separate examination.

If you were injured, keep records of injuries and expenses and correspondence with the insurer. If you were the driver, provide the policy and any claim received. A conclusion on one type of liability should not be automatically transferred to the other.

For advice after a road accident, contact lawyer Mihail Tomov or another lawyer at Tomovi Law Firm. We offer defence in criminal cases and assistance to people injured in road accidents after reviewing the specific evidence, without promising a particular outcome.

☎ Call for a consultation

Legal sources: Criminal Code — Articles 13 and 15; Supreme Court of Cassation, Judgment No. 213 of 14 January 2019 in Criminal Case No. 970/2018; Obligations and Contracts Act — Article 46(2).

This article provides general information and does not constitute legal advice or a legal consultation. For a specific case, consult a lawyer who can review the documents, applicable law and deadlines.