Непознаването на закона не е извинение.
(Латинска сентенция)
BG EN RU

Lawyer Mihail Tomov speaks to Capital

Media outlet: Capital newspaper

In “Now you own a company, now you don’t”, Capital examines unlawful changes to the ownership and management of a company with extensive property holdings. Mihail Tomov, the lawyer representing the company in court, describes the steps taken to protect it, the interim measures imposed, the application to stay the registration proceedings and the successful restoration of ownership to the owners, one of whom is a foreign national.

This publication forms part of the firm’s media archive. It records the events and the legal framework within which the lawyers specialise and practise.

Read the article in Capital

The original article is on the newspaper’s website. A subscription may be required for full access.

Source: Capital, 21 March 2016 · Original article in the Capital archive

Now you own a company, now you don’t

How a loophole in the law and the state’s unwillingness to act can cost businesses millions

Imagine deciding to go into real estate. You register a company, buy attractive plots, find business partners and invest. Business takes off. Then one day you discover that your company has been stolen, it owes a quarter of a million leva on a fictitious loan, and your best properties have been attached and are about to be put up for public auction.

This is a real scenario, one that has become particularly frequent of late, and most state institutions seem unable to respond adequately. The victim’s entire business is paralysed until the case is unravelled, which can take more than a year. That is the best-case scenario: it assumes the malicious acts are stopped in time. The Ministry of Justice has published proposed amendments to the Commerce Act on its website that are intended to make such practices considerably more difficult. In reality, institutional inaction is proving to be the far greater problem. Although this is one particular case, it exposes gaps throughout the system.

The case

In 2005 Hristo Vasilev and Cypriot national Sotirios Mihail formed Happy Lands OOD, a limited liability company whose principal business was the sale of real estate. By 2014 it owned more than 230 plots in Bulgaria, including land near Balchik. In mid-October that year Vasilev, then in the United Kingdom, discovered that the company had a new owner, Ivaylo Georgiev, whom neither he nor Sotirios Mihail knew. A claim was immediately lodged in court seeking a declaration that the registered particulars were null and void. The declaration was obtained and Hristo Vasilev was registered as manager again a year later. In the meantime, however, Ivaylo Georgiev transferred his shares to a third person, Ivan Stefanov, and the plots near Balchik were listed for sale with an estate agent. The scheme was a classic case of “stealing a company with an electronic signature”.

The scheme

The scheme itself is not particularly complicated. A person with little schooling or in financial hardship is offered about 300 leva to register an electronic signature, and the targeted company is transferred into that person’s name. False documents are drawn up (a resolution of the company’s general meeting, a contract certified before a notary, and so on) and used to register that person electronically as manager in the Commercial Register. A broker and prospective buyers are then found for the company’s properties. If no one notices before they are sold, the operation succeeds.

Stopping these acts, however, is far from easy. The latest attempt to steal Happy Lands came just a week ago: on 9 March it was again transferred to the same Ivan Stefanov. Hristo Vasilev received a text alert about the new documents. Mihail Tomov, the company’s lawyer, described the steps they took. They applied to Varna Regional Court for an attachment of the company shares. It turned out, however, that the shares had already been transferred, although the Commercial Register did not yet reflect this. Since the register’s electronic system processes changes in the order in which they are filed, it would record the ownership change first and the attachments afterwards, making the latter legally pointless. They also asked the court to stay the registration proceedings. Varna Regional Court ultimately ordered a stay. That saved the company from another change of ownership, but it took three days of intensive work. Court proceedings still lie ahead to have the registration of the false owner declared null and void.

The state investigates

In October 2014 the owners of Happy Lands reported the matter to the Economic Police, Financial Intelligence and the prosecution service. The result: the “investigation” dragged on for more than a year. At its height, two police officers came to Hristo Vasilev’s home to ask whether he knew anything about his stolen company. Meanwhile, it emerged that the investigating officers in the Economic Police had difficulty using the Commercial Register’s electronic system. The investigation was delayed, the prosecution service was not particularly active either, and no one had been detained at the time of writing.

Eventually Mihail Tomov, the lawyer for Happy Lands, decided to refer the matter to the State Agency for National Security (DANS). Since the interests of foreign investors were also involved, the agency responded immediately. In just three weeks all the front men and perpetrators were located and questioned. One of the front men, Ivan Stefanov, who had been unemployed for ten years, said in his statement that two young men had bought him a beer and asked if he would like to earn some money. He agreed. They explained that a company would be transferred into his name and that he would receive 300 leva. The transferor was Ivaylo Georgiev himself, who had also been looking for a way to make quick money. In addition to the company being put in Georgiev’s name, an electronic signature was obtained in his name and later used to transfer the company electronically through the Commercial Register. DANS identified the “two young men” as Yuliyan Dimitrov and Kosta Yordanov. It subsequently emerged that they were far from the only people involved and that Happy Lands was not the only company targeted in this way. DANS referred the case to the Varna prosecution service, which ultimately passed it to the Specialised Prosecutor’s Office in Sofia. The pretrial proceedings are against an unidentified perpetrator.

A third person, Ivan Vichev of Shumen, is also involved in the scheme. He is believed to have had the front man Stefanov sign a false loan agreement for 250,000 leva with a company owned by foreign nationals, this time Russians. The Economic Police established that they had not set foot in Bulgaria since 2008. The claim was also assigned to a third company, and Vichev obtained a writ of execution on the strength of it. To obtain the writ, he presented the court with a fabricated document purporting to show payment of a state fee of 5,000 leva.

He took the writ to Yasen Boychev, an enforcement officer in Shumen, who attached Happy Lands properties near Shumen and advertised them for public auction. Hristo Vasilev asked him for access to the enforcement case file but was refused on the ground that he had no legal interest, even though by then he was again the manager of Happy Lands. After being told that the properties were the subject of a crime, Boychev initially postponed the sale and ultimately called it off.

Institutions that do not work

The case reveals several things. First, it shows how easily harm can be done to anyone who does not regularly check their company’s entry in the Commercial Register or subscribe to text alerts. The process of countering such acts is particularly laborious: there is no quick and easy way to stop them, and going to court is essential.

Widespread institutional inaction makes matters still worse; the state shows no willingness to protect private property from such interference. Tellingly, almost two years after the first theft of Happy Lands, no one has been detained, while attempts have been made in the meantime to take over many other companies using the same scheme. The events of 9 March are particularly striking: a second attempt to steal the real estate company was made by someone who for nearly two years (!) had been under investigation by the Economic Police and the prosecution service for stealing … the very same company.

The relative ease of making such malicious changes in the Commercial Register is far from the greatest problem here. Electronic filing and public access to the register spare businesses far more headaches, and to some extent justify the risk. The proposed amendments to the Commerce Act follow the same logic. The Ministry of Justice proposes that transfers of entire companies or shares in them, the admission of new members and the expulsion of existing ones should require notarial certification of both the signatures and the content of the relevant document. At present only the signatures need to be certified. This would tighten the requirements for such changes without affecting public access to the Commercial Register, since no amendments to the act governing it are envisaged, at least at this stage. Institutional inaction is far more damaging. Any number of reasons might be given for it, from deep-seated corruption to plain laziness. Its direct effect, however, is all too visible: when institutions function poorly, so does society.

Source: Capital, 21 March 2016 · Original article in the Capital archive

Tomovi Law Firm offers advice and representation in commercial and corporate disputes. A timely legal review can help identify an appropriate remedy, without promising a particular outcome.

Call for a consultation